Module 1 · Lesson 6 of 10

Honest claims

Selling honestly is not just kind, it is a legal and commercial standard. This lesson covers how to prove what you say, how reviews and endorsements are regulated, how to disclose paid relationships, and how to persuade without pressure tactics.

About 55 minutesCore knowledge, games, claim audit

Every page you publish makes promises: in the headline, in the screenshots, in the star ratings, even in the countdown timer. In the United States and most other places, the basic rule is the same: advertising must be truthful, must not be misleading, and claims must be backed up before you make them.

01The standard: truthful, not misleading, substantiated

Three ideas from FTC guidance explain most advertising rules:

Truthful and not misleadingAn ad is deceptive if it contains a statement, or leaves out information, that is likely to mislead reasonable consumers about something important.
Net impressionWhat counts is the overall message a reasonable person takes away, including visuals, layout and what is not said, not just the literal words.
SubstantiationYou need a reasonable basis, meaning evidence, before you make an objective claim. Evidence collected afterward is too late.

Notice that a technically true sentence can still mislead. "Over 10,000 downloads!" is deceptive if 9,900 of them were free-trial installs that never opened the app and you imply paying customers. Look at the whole impression, not each sentence.

02Claims, puffery and promises

Not every upbeat statement needs proof. Regulators distinguish between kinds of statements:

KindExampleNeeds evidence?
Puffery"The best coffee in town!" "Our designs are stunning."Generally no: vague, subjective exaggeration that reasonable people do not take as a measurable fact. But the more specific it becomes, the less likely it is puffery.
Objective claim"Loads 2x faster than the leading plugin." "Used by 5,000 teams."Yes. You need data you can show, before you publish.
Comparison"Cheaper than [Competitor]."Yes, and the comparison must be fair and current.
Results or earnings claim"Students make $3,000 a month."Yes, strongly. These are high-risk, and typical results matter (see below).
Health, safety, financial claims"Lowers anxiety." "Pays off debt faster."Stricter proof is expected. Avoid unless you are qualified and have strong evidence.
Promise or guarantee"Money-back guarantee."The terms must be clear, and you must honor them.
Game

Puffery or a claim that needs proof?

03Reviews and testimonials

Reviews are persuasive because strangers trust other customers more than sellers. That makes them a regulatory focus. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, announced in August 2024, bans several practices that businesses of any size can fall into. In summary, it prohibits:

  • Fake or false reviews and testimonials, including ones that misrepresent the reviewer's experience or do not reflect real experience. This includes AI-generated fake reviews.
  • Buying positive or negative reviews, and offering compensation or incentives conditioned on a particular sentiment.
  • Undisclosed insider reviews, such as reviews by employees, owners or relatives that do not clearly disclose the relationship.
  • Company-controlled "independent" review sites that pretend to be neutral.
  • Review suppression, including threats or intimidation to stop honest negative reviews or to get them removed.
  • Buying or selling fake social media followers, views or likes to misrepresent influence for commercial purposes.

The FTC can pursue civil penalties against those who knowingly violate the rule, and platforms may remove violators independently. Rules and enforcement continue to develop, so check the FTC's page for the latest.

How to build real social proof
  • Ask real customers for honest feedback after they have used the product. Don't pre-write it.
  • Show the good and the mixed. A page with only perfect scores looks suspicious.
  • Do not edit testimonials to change their meaning. If you shorten one, keep it accurate.
  • Get permission before using a customer's name or photo in marketing.
  • If you offer a free product, discount or perk for a review, say so and do not condition it on being positive.
  • Respond to negative reviews calmly and offer to fix the problem. Never threaten reviewers.
  • If you have no reviews yet, say you are new.

04Endorsements, affiliates and disclosures

If you recommend a product and have a material connection to the seller, that is, something that might affect how much weight people give your recommendation, you need to disclose it. Under the FTC's Endorsement Guides (updated in 2023), material connections include:

  • Payment or commissions, including affiliate links
  • Free or discounted products or services
  • Early access, gifts or other perks
  • Business, family or employment relationships

The key requirement is that the disclosure be clear and conspicuous: placed where people will see it, in plain language, and understandable. Burying it in a block of hashtags, behind a "more" button, or in a separate page is not enough.

Clear

  • "Ad:" or "Paid partnership" at the start of the post
  • "I earn a commission if you buy through this link" next to the link
  • "Gifted by the brand" stated near the recommendation
  • A disclosure in the video itself, spoken and shown, not only in the description

Not clear

  • A vague hashtag like #sp, #collab or #partner that the audience may not understand
  • Disclosure buried among a pile of hashtags
  • A "commissionable link" label, which the FTC has said is not clear enough for affiliate links
  • A disclosure only on a different page

Responsibility is shared: advertisers, endorsers (such as influencers) and intermediaries can each be liable. If you pay people to promote your product, give them clear disclosure instructions and monitor what they post.

05Earnings and results claims

"I made $10,000 in a month" and "Our students earn six figures" are among the most scrutinized claims in online business. Regulators worry about them because they depend on a buyer's hope.

  • If you show results, they must be real and you must be able to document them.
  • Cherry-picking the best outcome implies it is typical. If it is not, a footnote such as "results not typical" is generally not enough on its own. You should tell people what results to generally expect if the impression would otherwise mislead.
  • A lifestyle photo (a rented sports car, a beach laptop) can imply income on its own. Net impression applies to images as well as text.
  • Do not claim, or imply, that a product will make money without real evidence that most buyers can.
A better way to talk about results

Instead of "Make $1,000 in your first week!", try: "This course teaches how to set up and sell a digital product. In our first cohort of 42 people, 9 made at least one sale in the first 60 days and the median revenue was $0. Results depend on effort, skill and market conditions." That might sell fewer courses. It also sells to the right people and builds trust that lasts.

06Urgency, scarcity and pricing

Persuasion is allowed. Manufactured pressure is not. These are common tactics that cross the line:

  • Fake countdown timers that reset for every visitor.
  • False scarcity: "Only 3 left!" when stock is unlimited.
  • Fake reference prices: "Was $199, now $49" when it was never sold at $199.
  • Hidden or surprise fees added at checkout. Show the total price early.
  • Hard-to-cancel subscriptions. In the U.S., the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act (ROSCA) generally requires clear disclosure of terms and a simple way to cancel for online "negative option" sales. Regardless of the exact rule, make cancelling as easy as signing up.
  • Guilt-trip buttons like "No thanks, I don't care about my success."

Honest urgency is fine: a real deadline for a real cohort, a real limited run, a real end date for a discount. If you can explain the reason plainly and truthfully, it is honest.

07Write it honestly: rewrite practice

Game

Pick the honest rewrite

08Your claim audit

Hands-on

Audit a page you plan to publish

Choose a real or imagined page. List the factual claims it makes, how you would prove each, and your honest version if you cannot.

Claim I want to makeEvidence I haveHonest version

Saved automatically Saved

09Check your understanding

Knowledge check

Lesson 6 quiz

10Key terms

SubstantiationEvidence that supports a claim, held before the claim is made.
Net impressionThe overall message a claim, image or omission conveys.
PufferyVague, subjective praise no one takes as a measurable fact.
Material connectionA relationship that could affect how people view an endorsement.
Clear and conspicuousEasy to notice and understand, in the right place.
Dark patternA design that tricks or pressures people into choices they didn't intend.
Negative optionA sale where silence or inaction is treated as acceptance, like auto-renewal.
Reference priceThe "regular" price compared to a sale price.
Go deeperComparative claims and competitors

Comparing yourself to competitors is allowed if it is truthful and fair. Compare like with like, use current information, and be able to prove it. Do not disparage competitors with unsupported statements, which can raise defamation and unfair competition concerns on top of advertising rules. Naming a competitor also touches trademark rules covered in Lesson 5.

Go deeperOutside the United States

Many countries have consumer-protection and advertising rules at least as strict as the FTC's, and some require extra disclosures (for example, clear pricing and cooling-off rights). If you sell to people in another country, their rules can apply. Check the local consumer authority and the platforms you use.

Key takeaways

  • Advertising must be truthful, not misleading and substantiated before you publish it.
  • Judge by net impression: images, omissions and layout count as much as words.
  • Reviews must be real. Fake, bought or conditioned reviews, suppression and fake followers are prohibited under the FTC rule.
  • Disclose material connections (payments, affiliate links, gifts) clearly and close to the recommendation.
  • Earnings claims need real, documentable evidence and honest context about typical results.
  • Use honest urgency: real deadlines for real reasons, with clear total prices and easy cancellation.

Finished this lesson?

Mark it complete to save your progress to this device and your account.

Saved. Next up: Privacy and people's data.Next lesson